I. The Fundamental Distinction: Feedback vs. Review
The most crucial error both buyers and sellers make is confusing Amazon's two separate evaluation systems: Product Reviews and Seller Feedback.
| Evaluation Type | Purpose | Key Focus Areas |
| Product Review | Evaluating the item itself. | Quality, durability, design, functionality, value for money. |
| Seller Feedback | Evaluating the third-party seller's performance. | Shipping speed, packaging quality, communication, inventory accuracy, fulfillment. |
Rule of Thumb: If you purchased directly from Amazon, you cannot leave seller feedback. Feedback is reserved solely for third-party merchants. If a product breaks due to cheap manufacturing, it's a review issue; if the package arrives damaged due to poor packaging, it's a feedback issue.
II. For Buyers: How to Use Feedback Responsibly
Leaving effective seller feedback involves more than just clicking stars—it requires a strategic approach.
1. Pre-Feedback Diplomacy: Contact the Seller First
Before leaving a negative rating, always attempt to resolve the issue directly with the seller.
-
The Benefit: Most reputable sellers are highly motivated to offer a refund or replacement to maintain their stellar rating. Contacting them first gives them a chance to fix the mistake and shows good faith on your part.
-
The Outcome: If the seller swiftly resolves the problem, you should leave them positive feedback or, at minimum, no feedback at all. Only if the seller ignores your requests or explicitly refuses to remedy the error should you proceed with a negative rating. In severe cases, an A-to-z Guarantee Claim may be warranted.
2. The Anatomy of Effective Feedback
When leaving feedback, you submit a written comment and a 1-to-5 star rating.
-
Written Comment Focus: Stick strictly to the seller's logistics performance.
Example of Good Feedback: "The seller shipped the item two days early. The protective packaging was excellent, securing fragile contents despite the outer box damage."
Example of Bad Feedback: "The item broke after three days, but the seller responded quickly and offered a full refund immediately. A++ for customer service." (The comment addresses performance, but the rating should reflect the A++ service.)
-
Star Rating Guidance: Reserve 1- and 2-star ratings for truly miserable experiences (e.g., item never arrived and seller ignored all communication). A slight delay might warrant a 4-star rating, while exceptional service deserves 5 stars.
3. Modifying or Removing Feedback
While you cannot change the content of posted feedback, you can remove it within 60 days of posting.
-
When to Remove: Removing negative feedback is a valuable action if a seller rectified an issue after you posted a hasty complaint. It helps both parties and demonstrates good karma.
-
How to Remove: You can manage your submitted feedback by visiting the dedicated page: https://www.amazon.com/feedback
III. For Sellers: Winning the Rating Game and Managing Negatives
Your Amazon Seller Rating directly impacts sales volume and the ability to win the crucial Buy Box. A low rating can cripple your business.
1. Strategies for Achieving 5-Star Ratings
A high rating is earned through meticulous fulfillment practices:
-
Exceptional Fulfillment: Always package products meticulously to prevent transit damage. If creating a listing, ensure product descriptions are 100% accurate to manage expectations.
-
Rapid Communication: Unhappy customers become angrier the longer they wait for a response. Integrate your Amazon messages with a helpdesk system to ensure you respond ASAP.
-
Inventory Accuracy: Cancelled orders are a guaranteed path to negative feedback. Keep your inventory logs meticulously updated.
-
Requesting Feedback: Proactively requesting feedback post-delivery is essential. Automation tools like CR Feedback, or using customized request messages, can dramatically increase positive responses. You can generate optimized feedback request templates using tools like: https://www.productreviews.vip/generate/amazon
2. Removing and Mitigating Negative Feedback
Since a customer can remove their feedback within 60 days, your first action must be to contact the buyer and try to resolve the issue (offer refunds/replacements).
-
Amazon’s Removal Policy (The Exceptions): If a customer refuses to remove the feedback, Amazon will only remove it if it meets these strict criteria:
-
It contains obscenities or profanity.
-
It includes personally identifiable information about you.
-
The entire comment is solely a product review (no mention of seller performance).
-
-
The Strike-Through Mitigation: If you utilize FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon) or Buy Shipping and the customer blames you for an error caused by Amazon's logistics or customer service, Amazon will not delete the feedback. Instead, they will strike through the comment and add a note stating they take responsibility for the fulfillment issue, which protects your rating score.
If any of the above exceptions apply, contact Amazon directly and ask them to remove or strike out the feedback.
IV. Summary: The Mutual Benefit of Good Feedback
Amazon functions optimally when both buyers and sellers approach the feedback system with fairness and clear communication.
-
Buyers: Always give sellers a fair chance to resolve mistakes before submitting negative feedback.
-
Sellers: Offer exceptional, proactive customer service to prevent bad feedback, and use resolution and proper policy knowledge to manage it when it appears.